Wallace (Daniel Radcliffe) and Chantry (Zoe Kazan) meet at a party while reading refrigerator magnet poetry and find that they have great chemistry... as friends. They form a relationship in which they talk about everything from movies to illnesses to disappointing Christmas presents. It's heavy interest at first sight but there is a problem - Chantry has a serious boyfriend.

Wallace falls hard for Chantry and Chantry must deal with her growing feelings for Wallace. Should friendship be squashed due to budding romantic influences or can they control their desire to simply enjoy the benefits of a platonic relationship.